ALL THAT’S LEFT OF YOU
Commencing in 1948, this story traces the life of the Palestinian Hammad family across three generations. Partly drawing on the real life experiences of director Cherien Dabis’s own relatives, it explores their struggles and resilience after they are forced to flee their comfortable home in the coastal city of Jaffa. Dabis also plays Hanan, the wife of schoolteacher Salim (Saleh Bakri) and mother to Noor (Muhammad Abed Elrahman). As a child, Noor witnesses his father being humiliated by Israeli soldiers and loses respect for him, viewing him as a traitor for complying with their demeaning orders. While Salim tries to survive quietly, Noor adopts the rebellious views of his grandfather Sharif (Mohammad Bakri). By the time Noor is a teenager, he is emotionally disconnected from his parents and is tragically shot by soldiers during a protest. Hanan and Salim are later forced to make a difficult ethical decision that tests their faith and requires consultation with their local Imam. Years later, Hanan recounts the family’s history of resistance and shares insights into Noor’s radicalised motivations. This is a character driven film that highlights the enduring connection a person feels toward their first home, regardless of how much distance or time has come between them. It is superbly acted and mention must be made of the incredible performance by child actor Sanad Alkabareti as young Noor. With the family initially being quite wealthy, their experience doesn’t feel typical of the everyday Palestinian struggle – they had the funds to leave Jaffa in a private vehicle, avoided living in refugee camps, and eventually emigrated to Canada. Yet I get the point that there is no discernment between rich or poor in this scenario. The last quarter of the plot becomes overly sentimental and dipped into unrealistic territory before the final scene pulls it back together. A tighter edit of at least 30 minutes would’ve benefited the story to make it more succinct. A thought provoking examination of exile and its emotional intergenerational trauma.
SCORE:
Amanda’s Score 6.9/10
Janette’s Score 7.5/10