MONSTER: THE LIZZIE BORDEN STORY
Ryan Murphy, who has to be the busiest producer in television, returns with the fourth instalment in his true crime ‘Monster’ franchise … only he forgot about the “true” part. His newest offering focusses on accused double axe murderer Lizzie Borden (Ella Betty) in 1892. She’s a quiet, wide eyed young woman living under duress with her emotionally absent father Andrew (Charlie Hunnam) and vicious stepmother Abby (Rebecca Hall). They’re both violent towards her and treat her with disdain. Lizzie finds a friend, confidant, and eventually lover, in maid Bridget Sullivan (Vicky Crieps). Sullivan expands Lizzie’s world and is the only person who shows her genuine kindness. When the abuse becomes unbearable, Lizzie plots her parent’s murder. After killing them both she’s subsequently charged by police, only to be found not guilty in court. Murphy makes Borden’s story fit his narrative, sacrificing historical accuracy for explicit content and shock value. There’s an unnecessary and ridiculous thread featuring serial killer Aileen Wuornos (Sarah Paulson) who’s presented as a sycophantically obsessed Lizzie Borden fan. There’s no evidence that Wuornos even knew who Lizzie was and all these scenes do is reaffirm that the show has strayed into fantasy territory. After a laborious build up, the eight episodes drag and the story could’ve easily been told in half the time. Crieps speaks with an inconsistent accent that annoyingly drops in and out, and Paulson caricatures Wuornos. As is synonymous with Murphys work, the soundtrack is brilliant and the costuming and sets have no expense spared. A bloody, graphic fabrication of female rage.
SCORE:
Alex's Score 5.9/10
Amanda’s Score 6.5/10